Serving Wichita & Surrounding Communities — After-Hours & Weekend Appointments Available: (316) 925-0125
Leaky Faucet

How to Fix a Leaky Faucet With Two Handles

October 28, 2026

Leaky faucet with two handles beside a removed stem and washer on a towel

The median home in Wichita was built in 1974, according to Census Bureau estimates, so plenty of two-handle faucets around here have decades of wear on their washers and seals. If you want to know how to fix a leaky faucet with two handles, shut off the water, take apart the handle that is leaking, and replace the worn part inside. On older compression faucets that part is a rubber washer. On newer faucets it is an O-ring or a cartridge. Astron Services in Wichita, KS, wrote this guide so you can tell which repair you are facing before you buy parts.

Find out which faucet you have and which side is leaking

Two handles do not mean two identical faucets. Most two-handle faucets use one of two designs, and the repair differs for each.

A compression faucet has a stem that screws down and presses a rubber washer against a seat. The handle turns several times from off to on, and it gets tighter as you close it. These are common on older sinks and tubs.

A cartridge or ceramic disk faucet has a sealed insert under each handle. The handle turns a quarter or half turn and feels smooth at the end. When one leaks, the fix is usually a new O-ring or a replacement cartridge.

Where the water shows up points to the cause:

  • Dripping from the spout while the faucet is off: a worn washer or damaged seat on a compression faucet, or a worn cartridge on the other design.
  • Water around the base of a handle: a worn O-ring on the stem, or a packing nut that has loosened.
  • Water pooling at the base of the faucet or spout: worn seals where the spout meets the deck, or a loose mounting nut underneath.

Here is a quick way to tell which handle is the culprit when the spout drips. Close just the hot shutoff valve under the sink. If the drip stops, the hot side is the problem. If it keeps dripping, close the cold valve and check again. You save yourself from taking apart the wrong handle.

The repair, step by step

You will need an adjustable wrench, screwdrivers, a small pick or flat blade, plumber's grease, and replacement parts that match your faucet. Keep a towel and a small bowl for screws nearby.

  1. Shut off the water. Turn the two shutoff valves under the sink clockwise until they stop, then open the faucet to drain the pressure. A tub or shower without local shutoffs means using the main shutoff for the house.
  2. Cover the drain. A rag or stopper keeps a dropped screw from disappearing.
  3. Remove the handle. Pry off the decorative cap, unscrew the screw under it, and lift the handle straight up. Mineral buildup can make it stick, so wiggle it gently instead of forcing it.
  4. Unscrew the bonnet or packing nut. This is the hex-shaped piece around the stem. Turn it counterclockwise, with a cloth around it to protect the finish.
  5. Pull the stem or cartridge. On a compression faucet, look at the rubber washer on the bottom of the stem. If it is flat, cracked, or hard, that is your leak. On a cartridge faucet, note which way the cartridge faces before you pull it, because it has to go back the same way.
  6. Replace the worn parts. Swap the washer and the O-ring on a compression stem. Run a fingertip over the seat inside the faucet body. If it feels rough or pitted, a new washer will not seal well and the seat needs work. On a cartridge model, install a replacement that matches the old one exactly.
  7. Grease and reassemble. Put a light coat of plumber's grease on the O-rings and threads, rebuild in reverse order, and snug the nuts without cranking on them.
  8. Turn the water back on slowly and check the spout and both handles for drips.

Take the old washer, O-ring, or cartridge to the hardware store. Parts that look alike often differ by a small fraction of an inch, and that is enough to keep leaking.

If you would rather hand the job off, Astron Services handles faucet repair for homes across the Wichita area.

Why this job gets tricky in older Wichita homes

A 1974 median build year means many houses here still have original fixtures, or fixtures that have been patched over several decades. Wichita also has about 176,000 housing units, and the Census Bureau puts 59% of them as owner-occupied. For most people reading this, the person doing the repair is also the person paying for it, so it helps to know early whether a quick fix will hold.

Old shutoff valves are the first trouble spot. Valves under the sink that have not been turned in years can stick, drip, or break when you finally try them. If one will not close fully, you will have to shut off the water to the whole house.

Old chrome and brass can also be corroded around the stem and bonnet. A stripped nut can turn a simple washer swap into a bigger plumbing job. And some older compression faucets use stems that are hard to find. At that point, replacing the faucet can take less time than hunting for a discontinued part.

One more local habit worth knowing about: the leak you find at the sink is not always the only one. Check the cabinet floor under the sink with a flashlight and a dry paper towel. If the wood is soft or stained, the leak has been going on longer than the drip suggests.

When a DIY fix stops making sense

Swapping a washer or cartridge is a reasonable project for many homeowners. Hand it to a plumber if any of these are true:

  • The shutoff valves will not close, or they leak when you touch them.
  • The stem or bonnet is stuck and will not turn without risking the faucet body.
  • You replaced the washer and the faucet still drips, which often points to a damaged seat or a worn body.
  • Matching parts is guesswork because the faucet is old or the brand is unknown.
  • Water is coming from the supply connections under the sink, not from the faucet.
  • The leak is inside a wall, such as a tub or shower with no access panel.

Cost depends on the faucet type, which parts are worn, how easy the plumbing is to reach, and whether repair or replacement makes more sense. We can only give you a real number once we know what is in your wall or under your sink, so call and describe what you see.

Astron Services is owned by Brian Stupasky and based in Wichita. Besides faucet repair, we handle drain cleaning, water service, and water heater repair and replacement, so a leak that turns out to be a supply line or drain problem does not need a second company. Google shows a 5.0 rating across 27 reviews for the business. We serve Andover, Bel Aire, Derby, Goddard, Haysville, Maize, Mulvane, Park City, Valley Center, and Wichita, including faucet repair in Derby.

A steady drip is worth fixing sooner rather than later. It wastes water, can stain the basin, and a leak at the base can seep into the cabinet and damage the wood.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my bathtub faucet handle leaking?

Usually a worn part inside the handle. On a compression tub faucet it is typically the stem washer or O-ring. On a cartridge tub faucet it is a worn O-ring or the cartridge itself. Water around the handle points to the stem seal, while a dripping spout points to the washer, seat, or cartridge.

How to repair a Peerless kitchen faucet?

First work out whether yours is a washer style or a cartridge style, since both designs exist across faucet brands. Shut off the water, remove the handle, pull the stem or cartridge, and replace the worn washer, O-ring, or cartridge. Match the part by model number, or take the old one to a supply store.

How to replace a two handle bathtub faucet?

Shut off the water, then remove both handles and the trim. Swapping stems or cartridges and trim is simple. Replacing the valve bodies inside the wall is different, since it can involve cutting copper pipe, soldering, or opening the wall. That part is a job for a plumber.

My Moen two-handle kitchen faucet is leaking around the base. What can I do to fix this?

Turn off the water and check for loose mounting hardware underneath. If it is snug and the leak continues, the seals or O-rings at the base or spout are likely worn. Cartridges and parts are brand specific, so match them by model number. If the faucet body is cracked or corroded, replacing the faucet is the better fix.

Do I need to shut off the water to fix a leaky faucet?

Yes. Close the shutoff valves under the sink, or the main shutoff if there are none, then open the faucet to drain the pressure. Working on a stem or cartridge with the water on can send a stream across the room. Confirm the flow has stopped before you unscrew anything.

Should I replace a leaky two-handle faucet or repair it?

Repair makes sense when parts are easy to find and the faucet body is in good shape. Replacement is often better when the faucet is heavily corroded, parts are discontinued, or you have already fixed the same leak more than once. A plumber can look at the faucet and tell you which route is more practical.

Get a leaking two-handle faucet looked at

If the drip is still there after a washer swap, or you would rather skip the wrenches, call Astron Services at (316) 925-0125. We are open Monday to Friday, 8am to 4pm, with after-hours and weekends by appointment. You can also read more about faucet repair from Astron Services before you call, or go straight to the Wichita faucet repair page.

Ready to Schedule Your Service?

Astron Services provides reliable plumbing, heating, and cooling service throughout the Wichita metro area — residential and light commercial.

Book Online Now ☎ (316) 925-0125